Fall 1993 access

Integrating Global Models: Conference Report

by Randall Graham, Science Writer, and Fran Bond, Publications Editor

"Ecological economics is an attempt to integrate social sciences and natural sciences in order to provide the information necessary to formulate policy dealing with global climate change," said Karl-Göran Maler, director of the Beijer International Institute for Ecological Economics, a research institute of the Royal Academy of Sciences, Stockholm, Sweden. "In order to do that, we have to construct an understanding of the processes which join the social systems to the natural systems."

Maler spoke to about 30 scientists who gathered for the Global Ecological Economic Modeling Conference in March at the Beckman Institute. NCSA co-sponsored the conference with the Beijer Institute. Robert Costanza, president of the International Society for Ecological Economics and a research affiliate of the Beijer Institute, coordinated the conference.

The conference focused on constructing a new global model of the Earth by joining techniques from social science and natural science. It is widely thought that such a model could clarify humankind's impact on Earth's ecosystems and climate [see access, July-September 1992].

Attendees gathered to form research alliances for the future and to collaborate on a preproposal for funding global modeling R&D. After a day of presentations that introduced each other's research and modeling processes, conferees divided into small working groups to discuss and hone issues that were then formulated into a formal document.

Ecology

"Our goal is to build an evolutionary, adaptive modeling environment rather than a specific model," explained Costanza, professor of ecology at the University of Maryland and director of the Maryland International Institute for Ecological Economics. "We want the model to continue to progress." He said that the model could be used in conflict resolution.

The conferees were seeking a new modular approach to model building that could evolve over time through adaptations and improvements. According to Costanza, they did not want to "build it once, get the answer, and quit." This was to be the first step in an ongoing endeavor.

Ecological Economics

NYU's Ecological Economist Faye Duchin said the timing could not have been better for linking the model she uses with those of others. "We have done a lot of theoretical work in the last decade that has not been brought in [to the model], and we were ready to rewrite the model to make it more transparent to others."

She and her colleagues use a model developed by the Nobelist Wassily Leontief. Duchin directs the Institute for Economic Analysis founded by Leontief.

Duchin felt the conference broke new ground: "At a conceptual level none of us are yet asking the most strategic global questions because each of us is only asking the questions that appear to be globally strategic in our own area."

Climate

Climatologists' models are complex because they render a number of variables in 3D. According to UIUC Professor of Atmospheric Sciences Michael Schlesinger, "The whole spectrum of human endeavors, including agriculture and the ability to maintain water quality, is influenced by climate. We do not have a good understanding of how this works, because we need information on the small scale at which impacts are felt.... We are also held back by our understanding of how the processes work in the climate system. The problem, as I see it, is to ask 'Well so what if climate changes?'"

Geography

UIUC Geography Professor Bruce Hannon was NCSA's host and co-coordinator for the conference. Together with an international group of scientists, including Costanza, Hannon visited the Beijer Institute in the summer of 1992. He returned in September 1993 for the 4th Annual International Complex Systems Conference. NCSA Director Larry Smarr also attended.

We are in "the infant stage of the modeling process," Hannon acknowledged. "Both data and the modeling process need to be addressed.... Although many of the ecological modelers are using STELLA, there was talk of needing [more complex] software to integrate the federation that goes into producing a large global model. NCSA has a software development initiative to address this."

As a participant in this initiative, Hannon is a visiting professor at NCSA, where he has been enhancing modeling techniques and running code on the CM-5 [see access, October-December 1992]. Albert Cheng, NCSA Software Development Group (SDG) programmer, is working with Hannon on this effort, which was demonstrated. Duchin showed a software program she developed with SDG Programmer Jason Ng.

Goals Of The Group

"We are interested in how to make connections between various models and also in how that coupling affects our model," said Hannon, summarizing the conference's goals. "For us it means moving from 30 x 60 meter cells to much larger ones for the global model."

Costanza joined in: "People at the conference are working on stand-alone parts of the global model.... What we want to view is the whole. This is conceived of as a 5-year project," he continued. "The model structure itself will be evolving."

The group dealt with seemingly astounding datasets in terms of variables, but their vision is equally challenging. Because the "endgame" of their efforts could have broad, worthwhile consequences, the group gathered at the conference were dedicated to the long term.

According to Duchin, this ingathering of researchers showed that "science can be used to solve real world problems.... The issue here," she said, "is that the way we are living on this planet is causing repercussions that are bound to feed back on us.... Our conviction is that [humankind is] probably going to have to make more significant changes in how we live than most people have allowed their imaginations to consider."


access * Fall 1993 * NCSA